Thursday, October 16, 2014
Chapter 3: Playing Hard To Get
Ah, yes, the quintessential dating tip: play hard to get. This is by far the most popular relationship advice I never take and never will take. All my life, I’ve been told that the best way to win a man’s heart is not through his stomach, but through telling him “no” over and over again so that he’s on his knees begging for me to say “yes.” With advice floating around such as “keep him guessing” and “don’t say ‘I love you’ first or else you’ll come off too aggressive,” this little game has contributed in large amounts to rape culture as well as society’s expectations and fantasies of women. A woman can’t sleep with a man too early on in the game, even if she wants to, because then she’ll be labeled as too easy: a slut. By encouraging women to say “no” even when they want to say “yes,” and then following up with, “He’ll eventually get the idea,” this wisdom destroys the meaning behind consent, No no longer means No.
I’ll admit, being a dark, mysterious ice queen never suited me anyway. Whenever I did try, it left a bad taste in my mouth–I was being dishonest and manipulative and it never quite sat right with me. And I'll confess that I feel that my dislike is justified; why should I should feel ashamed by my displays of affection? I know I’m being aggressive, but I don’t understand why females being aggressive is perceived as a bad thing. There were so many rules that contradicted each other, but always ended up with the same phrase, "Guys don't like that." Don't be too loud, guys don't like that. Don't be too quiet, guys don't like that. Don't be this, don't be that, guys don't like that.
Playing hard to get comes from and leads to a lack of respect for women and their thoughts. This is the same kind of attitude that results in rape, the sexual assault where consent was not explicitly given.
Don’t try to convince me to spread my legs or go on a date with you if I’m just not interested. While politicians and scumbags are free to deliberate over what makes rape “legitimate,” often times mulling over what the rape victim was wearing and if she was drunk or sober, the real problem comes from popular culture with stories of women who said “no” when they meant “yes,” or, in some cases, just needed a little creative nudge to say yes. If you need a plethora of examples, TV Tropes has them all listed out and categorized. Another one, charming titled "Rejection Affection," calls upon the trope in popular culture where the man doesn't take the hint (or, in most cases, can't understand what the word "no" means.) TV Tropes even says, "Expect the Stock Phrase "Your mouth says no, but your eyes say yes."" A phrase that I've heard numerous of times, and now, am prone to cringe when I hear them.
However, when we talk about playing hard to get, it doesn't sound that bad. It's like The Chase is the right thing to do. We pass this mentality along by saying: "Be patient, he'll call first if he likes you," followed up with a feel-good, “Trust me on this, you don't deserve a man who doesn't care about you.” (On an extreme, but hopefully not too extreme, tangent note: Fat talk also goes the same way. "You look good! Did you lose weight?" It's like we're passing off that someone wasn't as attractive before, but now are simply due to a little of weight loss.)
The unfortunate side effect of playing hard to get is the implication that consent can exist between two people even when one says otherwise. If consent becomes blurred, if "no" stops meaning "no", then how can we ever hope to figure out when someone actually means No? But this is not the only issue; males feel as though they are entitled to their "prize". They gave chase and, now, they want their reward. Even worse is when people groan and moan about being stuck in the friend zone; no woman owes you anything for treating them like decent human beings. But somehow, our society finds both actions excusable, thereby encouraging the continuation of this behavior.
The message that we send when we encourage playing hard to get is resistance is a form of flirtation. Through romanticizing one human being overpowering the will of the others, we look at love and sex as a game. We give abuse, both mental and physical, a green light. We encourage a rape culture and throw consent out the window; society transforms the norms for sexual and romantic politics into ones that reinforce the disregard women face from men.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think the playing hard to get is definitely a generalized statement made towards everyone, meaning that it's often not correct. Romance is oftentimes not easy and there aren't really any rules. If it helps, California just passed a law that states a solid "yes" is required for sex to be okay, so at least some politicians are on the same idea that you think.
ReplyDeleteExcellent post, Donna. You make a really good point about the not-obvious but still significant connection between rape culture and "advice" for girls and women like "be mysterious" and "play hard to get." Just as women are often taught, explicitly and implicitly, that they have to play games to "catch" a man, men are often given the message that women's desires are hard to interpret and that persistence will bring reward. It's all very messed up. And in my opinion, it's disrespectful to both women and men. We're human beings, not exotic birds engaged in some weird mating dance.
ReplyDeleteIn my experience, the best romantic relationships are also friendships. We don't play games with our friends or pretend to be less into them than we really are, and if we do, it's not considered intriguing or attractive, it's just confusing and manipulative. No means no, always, in every situation. And being straightforward and honest doesn't make things less romantic, it just makes things clear.
YASSSS. Love it. I feel like points like this one are very difficult to articulate. I'm sure that many girls have never thought about playing hard to get in this kind of light before. I never even made the connection between the two. I don't think that playing hard to get is necessarily absolutely wrong, but the fact that society promotes this idea can lead to awful consequences. Thank you for pointing this out.
ReplyDeleteProps to you for talking about such a relevant and important thing! This was a really well written post and throughout the whole thing I was interested and wanted to continue to keep reading. You did your research which made the post have even more dimensions and kept it fresh with the other perspectives. This is such an important topic and I am so glad you wrote about it, really!
ReplyDelete